The latest West Virginia Health Care Association e-News Update announced that the Office of Health Facility Licensure and Certification (OHFLAC) has put into place a new Independent Informal Dispute Resolution (IIDR) review of disputed deficiencies for all nursing homes in West Virginia. The new IIDR procedure goes into effect immediately and three out of state vendors experienced in IDRs were selected to be the third party reviewers. The current Informal Dispute Resolution (IDR) will remain as an alternative option.
According to the e-News Update, the new procedure will be detailed in a letter to providers when OHFLAC returns the Statement of Deficiencies to the provider after a survey. The letter will contain instructions on how to request an IIDR. OHFLAC is proposing to use the following language in the letters:
INFORMAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION:
In accordance with 42 CFR 488.331, you have an opportunity to question cited deficiencies through an informal dispute resolution process. To request an informal dispute resolution, please submit in writing the specific deficiencies being disputed and an explanation of why you are disputing those deficiencies to:
Informal Dispute Resolution Review Committee
Office of Health Facility Licensure and Certification
408 Leon Sullivan Way
Charleston, WV 25301-1713
You may also send your request via email to DHHR.OHFLAC.@wv.gov.
This request must be sent during the same ten (10) calendar days you have for submitting a Plan of Correction (POC) for the cited deficiencies and must be contained on a document separate from the CMS-2567L, which contains the POC.
You may choose between an informal dispute resolution (IDR) and an independent informal dispute resolution (IIDR). You must clearly indicate your choice in the attention line of your request and the subject line of your email. An IDR will be completed by OHFLAC staff not associated with the referenced survey event.
Per West Virginia State Code §16-5C-12a, an IIDR will be completed by an independent review organization. If an independent informal dispute resolution process is selected, the matter will be assigned to one of three independent review organizations accredited by the Utilization Review Accreditation Commission. The facility may be subject to certain costs such as:
• The cost of a face-to-face conference if one is requested; and
• The cost charged by the independent review organization, should the facility not be successful in its dispute.
Please call us at 304-346-4575 if you have any questions.
The new IIDR procedure will allow nursing homes an alternative option to the standard IDR process when questions arise during the survey process and related POC requirement. The new procedure will allow a nursing home provider to challenge the particular survey finding through an alternative/independent process. Whether this new alternative procedure will be valuable to nursing home providers is yet to be seen.